Supreme Court Won’t Hear Scientific Plastic Patent Appeal
Law360, New York (June 01, 2015, 2:38 PM ET) — The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear an appeal filed by Scientific Plastics Products Inc. challenging a lower court’s decision to invalidate three of its patents concerning the chemical …
Drug Discovery & DevelopmentShocking: 1 in 10 malaria drugs are of poor quality – Study finds
Dr Harparkash Kaur, who led the team said while the results raise concerns, they are reassuring in comparison with previous reports that found that more than 35% of antimalarials in sub-Saharan Africa failed chemical content analysis – in other words …
Substandard malaria drugs outnumber fakes, research shows
New Study in Nigeria Finds One in 10 Malaria Drugs Is of Poor Quality
Study in Nigeria Finds 1 in 10 Malaria Drugs Are Poor Quality
Drug Discovery & Development
An inventor’s perspective on patent reform
The Hill (blog)
There definitely are some bad apples out there – people who send spam demand letters based on questionable infringement of dubious patents. People like that are scam artists and should be shut down, and the FTC and state attorneys general are already …
Google’s Patent Purchase Program: In The Public Interest Or A Monopoly On …Mondaq News Alerts (registration)
Last week it was announced that Apple supplier Broadcom was being acquired by Avago Technologies. The consolidation in the semiconductor industry continues today with Intel Corporation and Altera Corporation announcing a definitive agreement …Continue Reading ...
Apple’s European headquarters employs 4,000 workers in Hollyhill Cork, Ireland where they make have an iMac production line. In Apple’s in-house …Continue Reading ...
The ConsumeristBlackBerry Settles Patent Dispute With Makes Of Slip-On Keyboard
nomore After another round of fighting over whether keyboard company Typo Products’ was infringing on BlackBerry’s patents, the two sides have decided to settle their dispute. Typo will still get to sell slip-on keyboards — as long as they’re of a …
BlackBerry Ltd, Typo Settle Keyboard Patent Lawsuit
BlackBerry settle patent infringement suit with Typo
BlackBerry settles patent suit with Typo device for iPhones
CBC.ca Toronto Sun- Reuters all 193 news articles »
PatLit is indebted to patent litigator Chris Ryan for his account of last week’s meeting of the European Patent Litigators Association (EPLIT) — this being its second annual meeting, which took place in the quietly efficient conference centre of the Hotel Jardins du Marais, Paris. Writes Chris:
The Association has, on the latest review of an upward curve of interest, 168 members from 17 countries. I didn’t count the delegates or conduct a statistical survey of the geographic mix but I estimate that there were 60-plus people there and I identified individuals from at least 9 different countries.
More effective reporters than this one would no doubt provide readers with a full summary of each presentation, including the progress reported by each of the Association’s Working Groups (Substantive Law, Qualifications, Costs, Privilege, Code of Conduct and Education/Training). I will do no more than record, with source accreditation, the various “take home” points I picked up.
A positive tone to the meeting was encouraged by:
- The recent dismissal by the CJEU of Spain’s challenge to the legality of the Unitary Patent Regulation;
- The failure of a similar challenge in the Belgian constitutional court;
- A statement by Margot Fröhlinger (Principal Director at the EPO) that the Italian government had decided that, subject to the approval of its parliament, it would now ratify the UPC Agreement; and
- The apparent intention of the EPO (again according to Margot Fröhlinger) to press ahead with a planned commencement date in 2016, without regard to the UK’s planned referendum on continued EU membership.
Patent Litigators Certificate
The next iteration of the Rules on the European Patent Litigation Certificate will provide that non-profit organisations (i.e. not only universities) will be entitled to seek course accreditation. This was a point of criticism of the last draft which was raised by CIPA’s Chris Mercer, in his capacity as Chair of the Working Group on Qualification, and subsequently clarified by Bernadette Makoski from the German Ministry of Justice during her review of “Development towards a litigators certificate for European Patent Attorneys.
It is not just senior members of the UK Patent Attorney profession who worry that the “grandfathering” route to qualify to represent clients before the Unified Patent Court is currently unclear and potentially unfair – delegates from other countries (including Germany) are also concerned. They received a sympathetic acknowledgement from Bernadette Makoski but, so far as I could detect, no unequivocal assurance that the final version of the rules will include them among those qualified to represent clients.
Bernadette did indicate that the approach likely to be adopted towards grandfathered qualification through previous course attendance is to be inclusive, in respect of qualifying courses (I think that means the list in the last draft will increase), but to give those wanting to make use of the provision a strictly enforced 12 months, and no more, to submit an application. The right to represent clients enjoyed by those qualifying by this route will be permanent – the provision is not transitional in that sense.
The rules are expected to be finalised in the course of this summer (Bernadette again).
There was an awful lot of detail (from both Eugen Popp of Meissner Bolte and Margot Fröhlinger ) on the recently proposed level of Unitary Patent renewal fees and the complex financial modelling that lies behind the current proposal to align them with the renewal cost of a European Patent designating the four or five most popular national jurisdictions. My strongest recollection of the day was the weariness in the voice of Margot Fröhlinger when faced with the prospect of re-calibrated financial modelling to reflect Italy’s change of heart and consequent replacement of the Netherlands as the fourth most popular country for European Patent designation. A final decision on this is expected within the (relatively wide) window of “end of June or in the fall”.
Value-based Court Fees
New to me (but maybe not others) was the explanation by Eugen Popp that if the UPC approach to valuing claims were to follow the approach that is well established in the German Courts, the pattern would be something like
* 80% based on an evaluation of the “cease and desist” element, taking account of:
§ Remaining life of the patent in suit;
§ Patent proprietor’s turnover, size and position in the market;
§ Magnitude of harmfulness of the infringing activity;
§ Potential loss resulting from the claim;
* 20% based on the available financial remedies.
More understandable was the importance of Rules of Procedure requiring the exercise to be carried out by the court early in the process and well before either side could seek to influence the conduct of the valuation exercise on the basis of the way the court seemed to be going.
While those used to high costs recovery (UK and Germany) were fairly relaxed about the recent proposals, others found the upper range alarming both in terms of the level and the adviser’s difficulty in evaluating a client’s cost risk within the €3M top-level cap.
Two minutes from me on the true horror of the detailed cost assessment procedures for courts in England and Wales did nothing to allay anyone’s fears about the court’s ability to come to the assistance of a client who has lost a high value claim.
Is it ironic that, as English procedures move to address the concerns of clients about costs risk that are both large and difficult to assess in advance (at least in the IPEC regime), the UPC recoverable cost proposals seem to be edging in the opposite direction.
Training for Technically Qualified Judges
Xavier Seuba from CEIPI at the Université de Strasbourg demonstrated that, in developing the soon-to-be-launched course for technical judges, a very careful analysis had been undertaken of the challenge of testing technical/scientific data in litigation and the precise nature of the role of a technical judge, as distinct from that of a court appointed expert (or others likely to have an impact on this aspect of patent trials). Not surprisingly, against that background, the course outline Xavier disclosed was impressive and the support for the course by both judges (as tutors) and potential trainees reportedly at a high level.
Rules of Procedure
18th draft expected during or after the summer (another fairly wide window) – this again from Margot Fröhlinger.
… after all the legal, procedural and political debate came a breath of fresh air when Max Brunner, from the French Ministry of Justice, gave a fascinating presentation on the project planning for the establishment of the Central Division in France. He included the chilling opinion that, based on long experience of managing projects, this was the most difficult one he had faced. The difficulties were in part due to the disbursed nature of the decision-making and, more particularly, the uncertainties – “project management without any reliable kick off date” he called it. And without any idea of how many cases would arise – how many filings and how many opt outs: what would the “litigation rate” be: and how many cases would end up in the local court or the central division in Paris.
Against the background of those difficulties M Brunner presented a hugely impressive (to this project non-manager) of the steps being taken in respect of premises, facilities, support staff planning and IT development. There was a passing suggestion on this last topic that the Paris team may not have been totally convinced by some of the security and user authentication features of the system presented by the UK IPO team during a recent workshop exercise.
The conference ended with a discussion by a panel of industry representatives. But, bearing in mind the circumstances in which the late Ruth Rendell lost her first job as a reporter on a local paper, I won’t include anything arising out of it in this report.
Thanks so much, Chris, for this detailed and helpful report!
ReutersBlackBerry settles patent dispute with Seacrest’s company Typo
In February, a U.S. district court sanctioned Typo, co-founded by “American Idol” host Seacrest, for violating an injunction that barred it from selling a $99 iPhone keyboard case that BlackBerry said infringed its patents. Physical keyboards have …
BlackBerry Ltd, Typo Settle Keyboard Patent LawsuitBidness ETC
BlackBerry Settles Patent Dispute With Makes Of Slip-On KeyboardThe Consumerist
BlackBerry settles patent dispute with Ryan Seacrest’s TypoToronto Sun
CBC.ca -Financial Post
all 77 news articles »
All subscribers to the popular video-streaming service are expected to get a new Netflix interface next monthContinue Reading ...
MDX Technology to Deliver Exegy Operational Content Into Excel
At the heart of Exegy’s product line are purpose-built, hardware-accelerated appliances derived from an extensive portfolio of patented and patent-pending technology. For more information, please visit www.exegy.com and follow Exegy on LinkedIn and …
According to a new supply chain report today, Taiwan-based flexible (FPCB) makers in the iPhone supply chain are likely to be forced to lower their prices …Continue Reading ...
Now… this is Ian (ed)This is a guest post by Ian Learmonth, following the discussion he lead last week on the case (see further commentary using the hashtag #SandtonDiscussion) especially as it relates to South Africa and other common law jurisd…Continue Reading ...
According to a new report published earlier today, Smartwatch display unit shipments are expected to grow 250 percent year-over-year, reaching a record 34 million units in 2015, led by demand for the new Apple Watch.Continue Reading ...
The European Patent Office (EPO) issues the highest quality patents of the world’s five biggest and most important patent offices, according to the respondents to this year’s IAM benchmarking survey.
Published in the latest issue of the magazine, which is now available to subscribers online, the benchmarking survey asked a series of questions relating to the performance of the IP5, which in addition to the EPO comprises the Japan Patent Office (JPO), the Korean IP Office (KIPO), China’s State IP Office (SIPO) and the US Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO).
Asked to state their perceptions of the quality of the patents awarded by…Continue Reading ...
Center For American ProgressPatent Tax Dodge: Why the Patent Box Does Not Answer America’s Need for Tax …
Center For American Progress
As a means of addressing competition from U.S.-based and other multinationals, some foreign governments are turning to the patent box, which offers domestic companies a favorable tax structure for royalties and other income that flows from the patents …
Microsoft’s Executive Vice President of Operating Systems Terry Myerson announced today in a Windows Blog entry that Windows 10 will be released to the public on July 29, 2015.Continue Reading ...
Zecotek Granted U.S. Patent for Switchable 3D/2D Optical Imaging SystemPR Newswire (press release)SINGAPORE, June 1, 2015 /PRNewswire/ – Zecotek Photonics Inc. (TSX-V: ZMS; Frankfurt: W1I), a developer of leading-edge photonics technologies for industr…Continue Reading ...
From a satire on plagiarism:
Several probes into local universities have found that plagiarism is rife, especially among international students, who are often permitted to enrol in expensive, full-fee degree courses with inadequate written and spoken English scores. A Parliamentary inquiry is not yet underway, but it’s expected that the government will plagiarise a committee proposal to announce to the public in coming weeks.
“Plagiarism is utterly unacceptable,” said one MP. “As soon as we’ve replaced the word Canada with the word Australia in the proposal, it’ll be released to the public.”
link to Report Into University Plagiarism Copied From Wikipedia:
See IPBiz post
Plagiarism and the H1B visa issue
including Plagiarism on rise at Australian universities as academics face pressure to pass international studentsContinue Reading ...
Ford is opening up its electric vehicle patents for licensing (not giving the technology for free). Not a big deal.The Christian Science Monitor “explains” why in the article:Ford shares electric car technology with rival automakers. Why?Ford is follo…Continue Reading ...
Drug Discovery & DevelopmentNew Study in Nigeria Finds One in 10 Malaria Drugs Is of Poor Quality
“Although these results raise concerns, they are reassuring in comparison with previous reports that found that more than 35 per cent of antimalarials in sub-Saharan Africa failed chemical content analysis – in other words, were poor quality. “This may …
Substandard malaria drugs outnumber fakes, research showsDaily Trust
Study in Nigeria Finds 1 in 10 Malaria Drugs Are Poor QualityDrug Discovery & Development